| Previous day | Wednesday 4 May 2016 | Next day |
| Troy 3 at Alabama State 1 | Recap | |
| Cornell at Binghamton | "CCD, impending weather" | |
| Quinnipiac at Bryant | "CCD, weather and field conditions" | |
| Jacksonville at Central Florida | "PPD to 5/11, impending weather" | |
| Furman 6 at Clemson 7 (11) | Recap | |
| Maine 9 at Colby 3 | Recap | |
| High Point 5 at Davidson 6 (10) | Recap | |
| Winthrop 2 at East Tennessee State 1 | Recap | |
| Michigan 12 at Eastern Michigan 0 | Recap | |
| North Carolina A&T 6 at Elon 9 | Recap | |
| Belmont 11 at Evansville 1 | Recap | |
| Maryland-Baltimore County at George Mason | "CCD, inclement weather (makeup of 5/3 game)" | |
| Coppin State 3 at Georgetown 4 | Recap | |
| Alabama A&M 7 at Georgia State 8 | Recap | |
| Prairie View A&M 0 at Houston 8 | makeup of 3/9 game | |
| Southern Illinois 3 at Illinois 6 | Recap | |
| Northwestern 4 at Illinois-Chicago 5 | Recap | |
| Louisiana-Monroe 4 at Louisiana Tech 14 | Recap | |
| Florida Atlantic at Miami Florida | "PPD to 5/5, inclement weather" | |
| Morehead State at Miami Ohio | CCD | |
| Kansas 7 at Minnesota 12 | Recap | |
| Arkansas-Pine Bluff 1 at Mississippi 12 | Recap | |
| Long Island at New York Tech | "CCD, impending weather" | |
| Richmond 4 at Norfolk State 7 | Recap | |
| Wofford 8 at North Carolina-Asheville 10 | Recap | |
| North Dakota State 4 at North Dakota 2 | Recap | |
| Boston College 7 at Northeastern 6 | makeup of 3/22 game | |
| Alabama-Birmingham 3 at Ohio State 12 | Recap | |
| Maryland-Eastern Shore 9 at Pittsburgh 6 | Recap | |
| Lamar 2 at Rice 7 | Recap | |
| Texas Southern 0 at Sam Houston State 5 | Recap | |
| Grand Canyon 6 at San Jose State 7 | Recap | |
| Jacksonville State 7 at South Alabama 8 | Recap | |
| South Carolina-Upstate 1 at South Carolina 4 | Recap | |
| Jackson State 0 at Southeastern Louisiana 15 | Recap | |
| Canisius 5 at St Bonaventure 8 | Recap | |
| Lehigh at St Peter's | "PPD to 5/5, impending weather" | |
| Florida State at Stetson | "PPD to 5/17, impending weather" | |
| Incarnate Word at Texas A&M | "CCD, scheduling conflict" | |
| UT Rio Grande Valley 0 at Texas A&M-Corpus Christi 3 | Recap | |
| Maryland vs Towson | "CCD, field conditions (Aberdeen, MD)" | |
| Manhattan at Wagner | "CCD, field conditions" | |
| Oakland at Western Michigan | "CCD, inclement weather" | |
| Kansas State 5 at Wichita State 2 | makeup of 4/26 game | |
| Parkside 2 at Wisconsin-Milwaukee 12 (7) | Recap |