| Previous day | Tuesday 10 May 2016 | Next day |
| Texas Tech 7 at Abilene Christian 2 | makeup of 4/26 game | |
| Northern Colorado 5 at Air Force 9 | Recap | |
| Samford 3 at Alabama-Birmingham 1 | Recap | |
| Memphis 3 at Arkansas State 4 | Recap | |
| Central Arkansas 9 at Arkansas-Pine Bluff 0 | Recap | |
| Troy 2 at Auburn 7 | Recap | |
| Middle Tennessee State 17 at Austin Peay State 3 | Recap | |
| McNeese State at Baylor | "CCD, inclement weather" | |
| Niagara 2 at Buffalo 9 (7) | makeup of 4/5 game | |
| Niagara 3 at Buffalo 4 (8) | makeup of 4/5 game | |
| UC Davis 7 at Cal State Sacramento 1 | Recap | |
| College of Charleston 4 at Clemson 13 | Recap | |
| Massachusetts 0 at Connecticut 5 | Recap | |
| Longwood 5 at Duke 11 | Recap | |
| Butler at Eastern Illinois | "CCD, impending weather" | |
| Campbell 2 at Elon 14 | Recap | |
| South Florida 4 at Florida 11 | Recap | |
| Mercer 6 at Florida A&M 7 (11) | Recap | |
| Cal Poly 5 at Fresno State 9 | Recap | |
| Savannah State 3 at Georgia Tech 21 | Recap | |
| Sacred Heart 7 at Hartford 4 | makeup of 4/5 game | |
| Wake Forest 9 at High Point 2 | Recap | |
| Kentucky 2 at Indiana 3 | Recap | |
| Florida State 2 at Jacksonville 6 | Recap | |
| Richmond 17 at James Madison 5 (8) | Recap | |
| Georgia State 2 at Kennesaw State 3 | Recap | |
| Tennessee Tech 8 at Lipscomb 12 | Recap | |
| Georgetown 4 at Maryland-Baltimore County 9 | Recap | |
| Northeastern 7 at Massachusetts-Lowell 2 | Recap | |
| Bethune-Cookman 7 at Miami Florida 14 | Recap | |
| San Francisco 5 at Nevada 6 | Recap | |
| Arizona State 6 at Nevada-Las Vegas 4 | Recap | |
| East Carolina 1 at North Carolina 9 | Recap | |
| Furman 4 at North Carolina-Asheville 3 | Recap | |
| Concordia (MN) 3 at North Dakota State 4 (10) | Recap | |
| Georgia Southern 4 at North Florida 13 | Recap | |
| Louisiana Tech 6 at Northwestern State 0 | Recap | |
| Louisiana State at Notre Dame | "PPD to 5/11, rain" | |
| Eastern Michigan 11 at Oakland 5 | Recap | |
| Marshall at Ohio | "CCD, impending weather" | |
| Florida Atlantic at Ohio State | "CCD, impending weather" | |
| Dallas Baptist 7 at Oklahoma State 8 (11) | Recap | |
| Gonzaga 5 at Oregon 4 | Recap | |
| Portland 7 vs Oregon State 5 | "Salem, OR" | |
| Youngstown State 3 at Pittsburgh 5 (5) | "5 innings, rain" | |
| IUPU-Fort Wayne 4 at Purdue 3 | Recap | |
| Houston 10 at Rice 0 | Recap | |
| Binghamton 7 at Siena 8 | Recap | |
| Presbyterian 1 at South Carolina 3 | Recap | |
| Jackson State 21 at Southern 3 (7) | makeup of 2/24 game | |
| Monmouth at St Joseph's | PPD to 5/11 | |
| San Jose State 4 at St Mary's 1 | Recap | |
| Santa Clara 3 at Stanford 10 | Recap | |
| Belmont 3 at Tennessee 5 | Recap | |
| Alabama A&M 1 at Tennessee-Martin 11 (8) | Recap | |
| Stephen F. Austin at Texas Christian | "PPD to 5/17, inclement weather" | |
| Houston Baptist 7 at Texas Southern 6 | Recap | |
| New Orleans 2 at Tulane 5 | Recap | |
| San Diego 3 at UC Irvine 9 | Recap | |
| Loyola Marymount 5 at UC Riverside 4 | Recap | |
| Cal State Bakersfield 5 at UC Santa Barbara 4 | Recap | |
| Pepperdine 4 at UCLA 1 | Recap | |
| Brigham Young 17 at Utah Valley State 6 | makeup of 4/26 game | |
| Louisville 8 at Vanderbilt 5 | Recap | |
| Long Island 3 at Villanova 4 | Recap | |
| Maryland 1 at West Virginia 4 | Recap | |
| Michigan State at Western Michigan | "CCD, inclement weather" | |
| Creighton 3 at Wichita State 7 | Recap | |
| Illinois State at Wisconsin-Milwaukee | "PPD to 5/11, impending weather" | |
| Northern Kentucky at Xavier | "CCD, inclement weather" |