| Previous day | Wednesday 11 May 2016 | Next day |
| Kennesaw State 7 at Auburn 3 | Resumption of 2/23 game | |
| Indiana State 16 at Ball State 8 | Recap | |
| McNeese State 12 at Baylor 7 | Recap | |
| Youngstown State 9 at Bowling Green State 5 | Recap | |
| Mississippi Valley State 1 at Central Arkansas 11 (8) | makeup of 3/9 game | |
| Jacksonville 3 at Central Florida 6 | makeup of 5/4 game | |
| Michigan 7 at Central Michigan 8 | Recap | |
| Chicago 5 at Chicago State 6 | Recap | |
| College of Charleston 11 at Clemson 4 | Recap | |
| George Washington at Delaware State | "CCD, inclement weather" | |
| Norfolk State 3 at Duke 4 (10) | Recap | |
| Millikin 1 at Eastern Illinois 4 (7) | Recap | |
| Austin Peay State at Evansville | "CCD, inclement weather" | |
| Mercer 22 at Florida A&M 5 (7) | Recap | |
| Florida Gulf Coast 11 at Florida State 8 (10) | Recap | |
| Western Carolina 0 at Georgia 6 | Recap | |
| North Florida 0 at Georgia Southern 2 | Recap | |
| Louisiana-Lafayette 2 at Houston 3 | Recap | |
| Old Dominion 6 at Liberty 7 | Recap | |
| Northwestern State 4 at Louisiana Tech 5 | makeup of 4/19 game | |
| Maryland-Eastern Shore at Maryland-Baltimore County | "CCD, rain" | |
| Massachusetts 3 at Massachusetts-Lowell 7 | Recap | |
| Eastern Michigan 2 vs Michigan State 3 | "Detroit, MI (Comerica Park)" | |
| Nebraska-Omaha 2 at Nebraska 8 | Recap | |
| Alcorn State 4 at Nicholls State 6 | makeup of 4/27 game | |
| Charleston Southern 1 at North Carolina Central 0 | Recap | |
| North Carolina-Greensboro 7 at North Carolina-Asheville 12 | Recap | |
| North Carolina 2 at North Carolina-Wilmington 6 | Recap | |
| South Dakota State 6 at North Dakota 3 | Recap | |
| South Dakota State at North Dakota | CCD | |
| Connecticut 9 at Northeastern 8 | makeup of 4/5 game | |
| Louisiana State 1 at Notre Dame 0 (11) | Recap | |
| Louisiana State 3 at Notre Dame 2 (7) | makeup of 5/10 game | |
| Western Michigan 4 at Oakland 9 | Recap | |
| Florida Atlantic 2 at Ohio State 10 | Recap | |
| Penn State 11 at Pittsburgh 6 | Recap | |
| Coppin State 6 at Richmond 5 (10) | Recap | |
| Washington State 4 at Seattle 7 | Recap | |
| Rider 4 at Seton Hall 10 | Recap | |
| Monmouth 2 at St Joseph's 14 | makeup of 5/10 game | |
| Incarnate Word 9 at Texas-San Antonio 8 | makeup of 3/9 game | |
| Winthrop 7 at The Citadel 1 | Recap | |
| Wright State 14 at Toledo 5 | Recap | |
| Mississippi State 7 at Troy 3 | Recap | |
| Southern 2 at Tulane 14 | Recap | |
| Purdue 10 at Valparaiso 13 | Recap | |
| Radford 3 at Virginia Military 4 | Recap | |
| Illinois State 3 at Wisconsin-Milwaukee 4 | makeup of 5/10 game |